New York Stock Exchange
TheStreet.comTheStreet.com
  Customer Service: 1-800-562-9571 
Home
PREMIUM SECTIONS
Latest Stories
Stock News
Tech Stocks
Commentary
International
Tools/Quotes
Portfolio Tracker
FREE SECTIONS
TSC Free
Markets
Personal Finance
Investing Basics
Community
TSC on Fox TV
Letters
Corrections
SEARCH THE SITE

Commentary : Herb on TheStreet
Is Barclays About to Turn the Fund World Upside Down?
By Herb Greenberg
Senior Columnist

6/8/99 6:30 AM ET


Barclays Global Investors is best known as the largest institutional investment manager. That may be about to change. The company has quietly applied with the SEC to start trading open-end "managed" index funds on the American Stock Exchange.

If approved, they wouldn't be the first funds to trade on an exchange; that honor goes to, among others, closed-end funds, which unlike open-end funds issue a limited number of shares. But their introduction could be the first step to the public's trading of all types of mutual funds, which could be a boon to the Amex.

Far-fetched? Perhaps, but a key component of the Barclays plan is that funds would be priced continuously throughout the trading day, just like any other stock, instead of just once a day at the market's close.

What's more, "many of the criticisms of mutual funds, such as high fees and taxes, would be eliminated," says financial adviser Robert Levitt of Levitt Novakoff in Boca Raton, Fla. The high fees would be substituted with a commission to a broker for handling the trade, rather than the fund manager in the form of a management charge. (There would still be a management fee, but it would be paltry compared with fees charged by typical mutual funds.)

Then there's the tax issue: By purchasing a fund that trades as a stock, rather than a fund, investors would no longer be directly responsible for capital gains incurred by the fund for trades by the manager. "The two things that control taxes [in open-end funds] are the portfolio manager and other investors through the cash they put in and out" of individual stocks and the funds themselves, Levitt says.

Don't closed-end funds already offer that tax bonus? Sure, but because they issue only a limited number of shares, the shares often trade at big discounts or premiums to the value of the portfolio, or the net asset value. Barclays contends that those premiums and discounts can generally be eliminated by an unlimited supply of shares. In fact, in its application, Barclays makes a point of saying that its funds would create "efficiencies in pricing ... and minimize the [underwriting] costs that are sometimes encountered" with closed-end funds.

How exactly Barclays is going to have an unlimited supply of shares that trade is unclear. Details are sketchy; the prospectus has not yet been issued and officials were unavailable for comment.

If some of this sounds familiar, though, it should, because Barclays' proposed funds are similar in concept to the Standard & Poor's depositary receipts, or SPDRs, and other products that already trade on the Amex. One difference is that SPDRs are unit trusts that trade a fixed portfolio, and they mirror a small number of indices. Barclays, however, has filed to trade, at the start, as many as 45 indices created by Standard & Poor's, Dow Jones and Russell. (Some aren't even in existence yet.)

Perhaps the biggest difference is that unlike SPDRs or even index funds, Barclays wants to add a level of active management to its funds by lending shares to short-sellers, and investing in derivatives, options and futures, tactics that it says "are desirable and in the interest of investors."

All of this sounds great to Levitt, who has been looking for ways to invest in sectors without taking the tax hit of an index or having to rely on the skills (or lack, thereof) of a sector fund manager. "If I could buy the same product like a mutual fund on an exchange and I could buy it cheaper with better tax efficiency, it would be tempting," he says.

If other advisers agree with Levitt, that could pose a challenge to the likes of index fund giant Vanguard Group, whose funds have low fees but are subjected to the same tax risks as other funds (though those taxes are often lower than taxes on some actively managed funds). Vanguard officials declined comment, but Levitt predicts, "This will be Goliath versus Goliath." home


Herb Greenberg writes daily for TheStreet.com. In keeping with TSC's editorial policy, he doesn't own or short individual stocks, though he owns stock in TheStreet.com. He also doesn't invest in hedge funds or other private investment partnerships. He welcomes your feedback at herb@thestreet.com. Greenberg also writes a monthly column for Fortune.

As originally published, this story contained an error. Please see Corrections and Clarifications.

Send letters to the editor to letters@thestreet.com. Top
Read our conflicts and disclosure policy.

  Enter symbol or name:
   

Browse
The Archive
Markets

Stock News

Personal Finance

Commentary

TSC TECHNICAL FORUM

ANDY KESSLER

BEHIND THE SCREEN

BOB GABELE

BUILDING BLOCKS

CHARTED TERRITORY

COMMENTARY FEATURES

DRINKS & DIVERSIONS

EASY MONEY

EDITOR'S LETTER

EURO CURRENTS

EYE TO THE KEYHOLE

FUNDAMENTAL QUESTIONS

GREED & FEAR

HERB ON THESTREET

HOW WE DID

INVESTORS' BOOKSHELF

JAMES K. GALBRAITH

JIM GRIFFIN

MARC CHANDLER

MARRIN'S CHRONICLES

MONEMAILBAG

POWER LINES

ROQUE'S GALLERY

SILICON BABYLON

SILICONSTREET.COM

SPORTS SCOOP

TSC MALL RAT

TSC WEEKENDER

TECH SAVVY

TECHNICIAN'S TAKE

THE BUYSIDER

THE CHARTIST

THE INVISIBLE MOUTH

THE NIGHTSTAND

THE RISK ARB

THE TASKMASTER

THIS WEEK IN IPOS

TRAVELING WITH WINGS

WING TIPS

WRONG! DISPATCHES FROM THE FRONT

WRONG! REAR ECHELON REVELATIONS

WRONG! TACTICS AND STRATEGIES

WRONG! TAKE TWO

Investing Basics

International

Tech Stocks

Community



Free: TSC Free | Markets | Personal Finance | Investing Basics | Community | TSC on Fox TV
Premium: Latest Stories | Stock News | Tech Stocks | Commentary | International | Tools/Quotes

Home | About Us | Help | Site Map | Top



 © 1999 TheStreet.com, All Rights Reserved.